The Compass Volatility Index (CVI)
A coupling-derived volatility index, and why it is not the CBOE VIX.
Compass reports a single scalar called the Compass Volatility Index (CVI). It looks superficially like the CBOE VIX — a number on a fixed scale that rises when things get hairy and falls when they don't. But the two indices answer different questions, are computed from different inputs, and are appropriate for different decisions. This essay explains how CVI is built, what it captures that VIX misses, and where the VIX is still the better tool.
What the VIX actually measures
The CBOE VIX is the market's 30-day forward expectation of S&P 500 return volatility, derived from the prices of out-of-the-money S&P options. It is a clean, observable, liquidity-weighted statistic about a single asset class (large-cap US equities). Its inputs are option prices; its output is annualized standard deviation in percentage points.
The VIX is excellent for what it is: a real-time gauge of equity-option dealer hedging cost. Traders use it because it is liquid, transparent, and tradeable through futures and ETPs. It is, however, blind to anything that is not already priced into S&P options. Geopolitical buildup, supply- chain stress, narrative drift, sovereign-legitimacy decay — if these are not yet expressed in equity-option implied vol, the VIX does not see them.
What the CVI measures
CVI is derived from the state of the six Compass nodes — Narrative (N), Legitimacy (G), Liquidity (Q), Logistics (S), Lethality (K), Learning (L) — and the coupling between them. Concretely, CVI summarizes three things at once:
- Node-state volatility. How much each node's scalar score is moving relative to its own recent baseline.
- Coupling intensity. How strongly nodes are driving each other right now (the off-diagonal weights of the modal oscillator).
- Mode-energy concentration. Whether the system's dynamics are concentrated in a small number of eigenmodes (fragile) or spread across many (resilient).
The output is a unitless scalar on [0, 1]. Zero means a calm system with weak coupling and well-spread mode energy; one means strongly-coupled nodes whose dynamics are concentrated in a single fast mode — the precondition for cascading failure.
Why these answer different questions
The VIX answers a market-microstructure question: how much do option dealers think the S&P could move in the next 30 days? The CVI answers a systems-state question: how tightly is the world right now wired for cascade?
These can disagree, and the disagreements are informative. Equity vol can be low while geopolitical coupling is high — the classic “everything is calm until it isn't.” Conversely, equity vol can spike on a single earnings event with no broader systemic implication. CVI will move on the first; VIX will move on the second.
For a portfolio manager hedging short-dated equity exposure, VIX is the right input. For an operator deciding whether to pre-position inventory, diversify a chokepoint, or stress- test a sovereign exposure, CVI is closer to the question being asked.
How CVI is constructed
At each tick of the resonance pipeline, Compass holds a 6-node state vector and a 6×6 coupling matrix. The scalar CVI is computed in three steps:
- Normalize per-node deltas against each node's 30-day rolling MAD (median absolute deviation). This makes the measure scale-invariant across nodes whose absolute scores live on different ranges.
- Eigendecompose the current coupling matrix and extract the spectral entropy of the eigenvalue magnitudes. Low entropy (energy concentrated in one mode) maps to high fragility.
- Combine the normalized-delta term and the one-minus-spectral-entropy term as a convex combination, then squash to [0, 1] via a logistic with parameters calibrated against the historical distribution of node states.
The implementation lives in RiskAnalyticsService.volatility_index (backend) and is surfaced through the same SSE pipeline that publishes node states, so the value the UI shows is bit-identical to the value used in scenario simulations.
How to read the number
- 0.00 – 0.25: Quiet system. Coupling weak, modes well-distributed. Routine operations.
- 0.25 – 0.50: Background activity. Some node motion, modest coupling. Worth watching narrative or chokepoint pages for context.
- 0.50 – 0.75: Elevated. Node deltas above their MAD baselines and / or coupling concentrating in a dominant mode. Time to revisit scenario assumptions.
- 0.75 – 1.00: Stressed. The system is wired for cascade. Most decisions should assume tail outcomes are not independent.
These bands are heuristics, not thresholds with statistical guarantees. The same CVI value can mean different things depending on which nodes are driving it — a high CVI on the Liquidity / Legitimacy axis is a different operational problem than a high CVI on the Logistics / Lethality axis. Always read CVI alongside the node-detail panels.
What CVI is not
- Not tradeable. There is no instrument whose payout tracks CVI. It is a decision-support index, not a hedging vehicle.
- Not market-implied. CVI does not contain forward-looking information that the market has not already priced in; it is a present-state summary, not a forecast.
- Not a substitute for VIX. If the question is “what does the equity-options market think about S&P vol?”, only the VIX answers it. CVI is complementary, not replacement.
- Not stationary. The same value today and a year ago may reflect different underlying dynamics. The bands above are recalibrated quarterly against the trailing distribution.
Why Compass does not display the VIX
Earlier versions of Compass surfaced the CBOE VIX directly as a system-stress proxy. We removed it for three reasons. First, conflating an equity-option statistic with systemic coupling was a category error and produced misleading signals when equity vol was suppressed by inflows but the underlying system was tightening. Second, CVI is computable from data Compass already produces, so the dependency on a third-party feed was unjustified. Third, for the questions Compass users actually ask — about chokepoints, sovereign exposure, narrative shock — CVI is the more honest answer.
If you are trading equity options, look at the VIX. If you are reasoning about the world the way Compass models it, look at CVI.
On the original VIX construction: Whaley, R. (1993). “Derivatives on Market Volatility: Hedging Tools Long Overdue.” Journal of Derivatives 1(1). On spectral measures of network fragility: May, R. M., Levin, S. A., & Sugihara, G. (2008). “Ecology for Bankers.” Nature 451: 893–895.